General News for the Wales Family 1: September 2022-March 2024


If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Prince William has always seemed very professional and has rarely put a foot wrong. Funny how people are questioning his ability to be Prince Regent or King for not attending a memorial service for an event that is largely more of a family event and, correct me if I'm wrong, is far from being a matter of State.
 
I respect that Kate and William want their privacy in particular with her recent health issues but after yesterday's statement I believe they could have given more clarity on the matter. I believe at some stage KP will have to give a better briefing on how the Princess is doing. Speculation is rife.

Maybe a new family picture could be released in time for Mother's Day in the UK in a few weeks
 
I’m a huge supporter of the Wales’; but I can’t help feel they have been poorly advised by the media department on this.

A picture of William visiting Catherine in hospital would have been something. Maybe taking the children with flowers. Or letting the Middletons be pictured.

I also feel sorry for them in regards to the fact Queen camilla was happy to be photographed going in and out of the hospital.

It’s almost like the two press offices are working against each other. One constantly wanting to show the country that Charles is okay , tending to paper work whilst it’s a dead wall from KP. Thus inviting all the speculation.

Reminds me of when public and press opinion turned against the Sussexes. Just my thoughts.
 
I’m a huge supporter of the Wales’; but I can’t help feel they have been poorly advised by the media department on this.

A picture of William visiting Catherine in hospital would have been something. Maybe taking the children with flowers. Or letting the Middletons be pictured.

I also feel sorry for them in regards to the fact Queen camilla was happy to be photographed going in and out of the hospital.

It’s almost like the two press offices are working against each other. One constantly wanting to show the country that Charles is okay , tending to paper work whilst it’s a dead wall from KP. Thus inviting all the speculation.

Reminds me of when public and press opinion turned against the Sussexes. Just my thoughts.
I understand the different points of view though. The King is the head of state and has a constitutional role in the UK. So it is understandable that an effort be made to show the nation that he is doing fine.

The Princess of Wales, despite being the wife of the heir and possibly the future queen consort, does not have any official constitutional role, so her health issues can be kept much more private.
 
The Protocole had to change all. Where would be His place at the Church , I suppose second place next to the Queen Consort and before Princess Anne ?
 
I think that it is a bit strange that there has been no real updates about the Princess. Not anything relating to what are her health issues because that is her own business.Just even a message on her letter head thanking everyone for their concern. It would just be a bit reassuring for the people.
 
Yes, I think especially when you compare it to Charles' actions - a statement to the public, a video and acknowledgement of letters received etc it does seem odd there has been basically silence about Catherine.

But William and Catherine are very private so I suspect they are quite happy with that.
 
Catherine is not the head of state. Charles, as Sovereign, has to show that he is capable and has all his faculties despite his diagnosis. Catherine, as Psow, doesn't have to and is afforded more privacy.
 
It does take time to make a full recovery from abdominal surgery, so I don't see that there's any need for people to speculate, but I agree that it wouldn't hurt for her to issue a statement thanking everyone for their good wishes etc, rather than the complete silence.
 
I think that it is a bit strange that there has been no real updates about the Princess. Not anything relating to what are her health issues because that is her own business.Just even a message on her letter head thanking everyone for their concern. It would just be a bit reassuring for the people.
That's a very interesting point. The King made sure to release some statement thanking all for their well-wishes etc. One could argue it's because he's sick and his disease, which is quite serious, was made public. On the contrary, the Princess has stayed silent and we don't even know if she's sick at all (there have been many people implying some plastic surgery instead), despite the many weeks of convalescence. Maybe the silence is because her health incident is not that serious? It could sound a bit dramatic if one releases a statement thanking everyone for their concern when there was not really a life threatening situation.
 
It does take time to make a full recovery from abdominal surgery, so I don't see that there's any need for people to speculate, but I agree that it wouldn't hurt for her to issue a statement thanking everyone for their good wishes etc, rather than the complete silence.
Agreed, but the time for that has passed imo. It would make more sense to release some "thank you" statement once she resumes her royal routine.
 
Catherine is not the head of state. Charles, as Sovereign, has to show that he is capable and has all his faculties despite his diagnosis. Catherine, as Psow, doesn't have to and is afforded more privacy.
From an official and technical point of view, you're quite right. The King as head of state is the most important person and has to be seen. But let's not be naive, from a public relations point of view, Catherine is the star of the show these days, there's no one who can command the same attention as she does now, her absence is a huge loss for The Firm. She's allowed, of course, to have privacy, but I wouldn't be surprised if there was some concern by palace aides without her on the picture.
 
I thought that there was a statement or report that she would be doing some work from her home/ bed while she was recuperating. If that is the case then that is why I am puzzled by the lack of any news or communication from her.
 
Although I agree that she is not the head of state, she does hold a very important role in the royal family which -- whether or not you agree -- is subject to public scrutiny. And while Catherine may know that, I don't know if she fully understands that.

I agree that her right to privacy is absolute, however not doing anything when you are a "public person" just gives rise to all types of suspicions, etc ...

At the very minimum, a staged photo op of her having tea with her family and/or the kids would show the public that she is O.K. She doesn't have to disclose anything, but she absolutely should do the very minimum -- a photo ... a thank you note ... anything. Silence is not a strategy.

JMHO
 
Although I agree that she is not the head of state, she does hold a very important role in the royal family which -- whether or not you agree -- is subject to public scrutiny. And while Catherine may know that, I don't know if she fully understands that.

I agree that her right to privacy is absolute, however not doing anything when you are a "public person" just gives rise to all types of suspicions, etc ...

At the very minimum, a staged photo op of her having tea with her family and/or the kids would show the public that she is O.K. She doesn't have to disclose anything, but she absolutely should do the very minimum -- a photo ... a thank you note ... anything. Silence is not a strategy.

JMHO
I respect your opinion but I really have to disagree strongly with this. In being a public figure there is always going to be a compromise in terms of privacy and I think they've reached a decent enough compromise. She had surgery, it requires a long recovery, and the Palace has updated us that she is recovering well. Every indication is that she will recover fully and return to her duties without issue. I find that quite enough and actually commend the Wales's(of whom I am not always the biggest fan) for keeping a firm boundary with the public. Just because the public wants to be nosey and create all sorts of theories doesn't mean the Wales's have to bow to that pressure and give up their right to privacy. They already give so much of their lives to the public.

We don't know what she had done except for the clarification that it is not cancer related. [......] We have no reason not the trust the Palace when they say that she is expected to make a full recovery and return to her duties at that point.
 
I respect your opinion but I really have to disagree strongly with this. In being a public figure there is always going to be a compromise in terms of privacy and I think they've reached a decent enough compromise. She had surgery, it requires a long recovery, and the Palace has updated us that she is recovering well. Every indication is that she will recover fully and return to her duties without issue. I find that quite enough and actually commend the Wales's(of whom I am not always the biggest fan) for keeping a firm boundary with the public. Just because the public wants to be nosey and create all sorts of theories doesn't mean the Wales's have to bow to that pressure and give up their right to privacy. They already give so much of their lives to the public.

We don't know what she had done except for the clarification that it is not cancer related. [......] We have no reason not the trust the Palace when they say that she is expected to make a full recovery and return to her duties at that point.
Well said. I think Palace disclosure has been adequate. There is a long period of convalescence, and there is no need to keep updating. If there was a radical downturn in health, I can see a need for updating the public, but barring that, it is best to let her recover in peace, and return to public duties in line with the previously indicated timeline.
 
In these modern times of 24 hour news, instant updates on social media, celebrities and influencers ( who have never influenced me by the way) we are becoming used to the constant drip drip of information from people who feel the need to share everything with us. We are now expecting the same from the RF, and it is not going down well that the Wales's are refusing to be drawn in.

They are entitled to their privacy, I think they did thank people when she first came out of the hospital. All the pressure to reveal details cannot be good for her recovery.

We do not need to know every detail, I will not deny it will be interesting when it all comes out , and I will be one of those interested.
 
I must add the communication service of BP is bad, unclear and evasive:
Cancer but not the prostate
Did not attend for personal reasons
Found dead in an adress in Gloucester.
 
Last edited:
Exactly. I'm in the communications business and I can say with some degree of certainty that any suspicions regarding all/any of these situations has been caused by the very poor choice of words in the Palace's statements. Very very poor.
 
I must add the communication service of BP is bad, unclear and evasive:
Cancer not not the prostate
Did not attend for personal reasons
Found dead in an adress in Gloucester.
Two things here, without derailing the thread, we need to note the difference between the palace statements and those from other services. Secondly do we need to know.
 
It is not like I am overly in doubt about the state of affairs - but suspicious it is! It is all a little bit much, what is going on in the UK. The King is ill, Princess Catherine was cut open, the husband of Lady Gabriella dead, Prince William has lost weight...

Some good news would be welcome!
 
I must add the communication service of BP is bad, unclear and evasive:
Cancer but not the prostate
Did not attend for personal reasons
Found dead in an adress in Gloucester.

I beg to differ. I don't think it is King's/ BP's communication that is bad, but rather Wales'/KP's.
Buckingham Palace has been very transparent regarding the King's health. They've only stopped short of telling us the type of cancer the King has. In my opinion, the public need not know that information. However, they've been conscious to show the King hard at work and the video of the King receiving those thousands of get well cards was just brilliant PR -good optics.

In contrast, Kensington Palace and the Wales' office has been as vague as ever. Failing to attend a short memorial service one's godfather (especially in lieu of the fact that he did not attend the funeral) for "personal reasons" sounds very trivial. Almost as though the Prince of Wales wasn't in the mood to go. Even if the PoW, just needed a "mental health day" that would have been more understandable and certainly in line with couple's agenda on promoting mental health.
I also believe it would've been good PR to show the family visiting Catherine at the hospital or even releasing a photo of the family at home together.
 
I beg to differ. I don't think it is King's/ BP's communication that is bad, but rather Wales'/KP's.
Buckingham Palace has been very transparent regarding the King's health. They've only stopped short of telling us the type of cancer the King has. In my opinion, the public need not know that information. However, they've been conscious to show the King hard at work and the video of the King receiving those thousands of get well cards was just brilliant PR -good optics.

In contrast, Kensington Palace and the Wales' office has been as vague as ever. Failing to attend a short memorial service one's godfather (especially in lieu of the fact that he did not attend the funeral) for "personal reasons" sounds very trivial. Almost as though the Prince of Wales wasn't in the mood to go. Even if the PoW, just needed a "mental health day" that would have been more understandable and certainly in line with couple's agenda on promoting mental health.
I also believe it would've been good PR to show the family visiting Catherine at the hospital or even releasing a photo of the family at home together.
100% agree.
 
It is often the communication teams that get blamed, but I would note that they can only ever announce what the royals involved authorize them to announce.

I agree with you, Alisa, that it's Kensington Palace that has been evasive and vague, not Buckingham Palace for the most part. While William and Catherine have the right to keep this information to themselves, I'm not sure it is ultimately wise to do so, since it creates a lot of speculation. While there is always speculation about the royals, when people realize that something is happening but they don't know what, it creates a lot more than usual.

Once again, Buckingham Palace did not say found dead at an address in Gloucestershire, it was the police, so the Palace cannot help that. Maybe one could say that the Palace was also vague about Thomas Kingston, but he was not the heir or spouse to the heir, so I think what the public can reasonably ask to know differs quite a bit...
 
.....
I also believe it would've been good PR to show the family visiting Catherine at the hospital or even releasing a photo of the family at home together.

I believe the hospital has a rule that no children or babies are allowed to visit. We do know that William and the King visited her.
 
I believe the hospital has a rule that no children or babies are allowed to visit. We do know that William and the King visited her.
Requests can be made to allow children to visit. If the couple and their PR people wanted it to happen it could have happen. The London Clinic would never a request made by the future King.
 
Requests can be made to allow children to visit. If the couple and their PR people wanted it to happen it could have happen. The London Clinic would never a request made by the future King.
Why should KP let the PR people dictate that they have to request London Clinic for a special favour?

It is also entirely possible the family visited by the back door and were not pictured.
 
I’m a huge supporter of the Wales’; but I can’t help feel they have been poorly advised by the media department on this.

A picture of William visiting Catherine in hospital would have been something. Maybe taking the children with flowers. Or letting the Middletons be pictured.

I also feel sorry for them in regards to the fact Queen camilla was happy to be photographed going in and out of the hospital.

It’s almost like the two press offices are working against each other. One constantly wanting to show the country that Charles is okay , tending to paper work whilst it’s a dead wall from KP. Thus inviting all the speculation.

Reminds me of when public and press opinion turned against the Sussexes. Just my thoughts.
The trajectory of Charles's illness compared to Catherine's was quite different, though, and I think that was likely one factor contributing to how each team has been managing their respective issues. Catherine would have known she was dealing with a significant medical issue from the start (no healthy person in their 40s is hospitalized for two weeks for something minor). In addition to the stress of her surgery and diagnosis, she and William had the needs of their three young children to consider. Given all that, I understand why they decided to go to ground for awhile, although I expect they will release more information eventually, maybe closer to the time Catherine is due to return to royal duties.

On the other hand, Charles decided to be open about what he thought was going to be a very routine and benign diagnosis, along with a minor medical procedure. There was very little down side to being open with the public in those circumstances. The cancer diagnosis would have come out of left field and would have been very difficult to keep private in light of the public and press already being focused on the King's health due to the prostate issue, not to mention the time off he needs to complete his treatment. I actually think Charles's team gave as little information as possible regarding the cancer, and wonder if they would have been so upfront if they'd known from the start what they were actually dealing with.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom