Quote:
Originally Posted by fandesacs2003
Sorry I thought that it was Grand Duchess Maria Valdimirovna and her son, who are the throne pretendants. What their relationship with late Prince Nocolas Romanovich?
|
Maria Vladimirovna comes from a total different line than her far cousin Prince Nicholas.
The claimants are split in factions. The two most important factions both desdent from Tsar Nicholas I. The line of Maria Vladimirovna descends from the eldest son of Tsar Nicolas I and is the most senior line:
Tsar Nicholas I
x Princess Charlotte of Prussia
= Tsar Alexander II
Tsar Alexander II
x Princess Marie of Hesse
= Grand Duke Vladimir Alexandrovich (brother of Tsar Alexander III)
Grand Duke Vladimir Alexandrovich
x Duchess Marie of Mecklenburg-Schwerin
= Grand Duke Kyrill Vladimirovich
Grand Duke Kyrill Vladimirovich
x Princess Victoria Melita of Edinburgh
= Grand Duke Vladimir Kyrillovich
Grand Duke Vladimir Kyrillovich
x Princess Leonida Georgievna Bagration-Moukhranskaya
= Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna
Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna
x Prince Franz-Wilhelm of Prussia
= Grand Duke Georgy, Prince of Prussia
As said the line of Maria Vladimirovna descends from the eldest son of Tsar Nicolas I and is the most senior line. The line of Prince Nicholas Romanovich descends from the third son of Tsar Nicholas I and is therefore junior to the line of Maria Vladimirovna.
Tsar Nicholas I
x Princess Charlotte of Prussia
= Grand Duke Nicholas Nicholayevich
Grand Duke Nicholas Nicholayevich
x Princess Alexandra of Oldenburg
= Grand Duke Pjotr Nicholayevich
Grand Duke Pjotr Nicholayevich
x Princess Milica of Montenegro
= Prince Roman Petrovich
Prince Roman Petrovich
x Countess Praskhiova Sheremeteeva
= Prince Nicholas Romanovich
Prince Nicholas Romanovich
x Countess Sveva della Gherardesca
= 3 daughters
So the deceased is very, very, very remotely related to Grand Duchess Maria Vladimorovna. The junior line claims that Maria Vladimirova can not be the successor since the marriages with Princess Victoria Melita of Edinburgh and with Princess Leonida Georgievna Bagration-Moukhranskaya were not strictly equal.
The other line sees marriages with Countess Praskhiova Sheremeteeva and Countess Sveva della Gherardesca, absolutely not equal at all but this is countered with the argument that Grand Dukes (= sons and male line Grandsons of Tsars) were bound to marry a strictly equal marriage. Other Romanovs were not bound by this strict requirement. So in the way of thinking of the junior line, the senior line (father and grandfather of Maria Vladimirovna) "violated" the strict requirement which did not count for the father of Nicholas Romanovich and his own marriage)...
Jaja.... I call that "very creative accountancy".