Kate vs. Chelsy - Page 2

lady_windsor · #21 08-01-2005, 03:41 AM

i can imagine kate marrying prince william. i think chelsy and harry wont last very long. thats just my opinion

segolen · #22 08-01-2005, 04:04 AM

why not? i know Wills is too young , but why not.

ailstalia · #23 08-01-2005, 11:41 AM

the photo of chelsy is so unflattering that i think the article isn't fair, despite the fact that i like kate more to begin with. also, it portrays one doing something healthy and normal like biking, and the other as some kind of drunk looking party girl with a drink in her hand

Harry's polo shirt · #24 08-02-2005, 11:06 PM

I agree. they should look at every aspect. Kate goes clubbing too. they should fairly compair the two. I don't like Chelsey on the fact that I don't think she is right for Harry.
Harry needs someone to love him unconditinaly and to control him in a way. I don't think Prince Charles really supports the relationship. Prince Charles knows what it is like for your parents to disaprove of love, ie Camila and he doesn't want harry to end up like himself. thats my opinion.

polop · #25 08-03-2005, 06:58 PM

Quite honestly, Kate is just a little better than Chelsy. I mean Kate is such a "good girl" it ANNOYING!!! She goes clubbing in jeans and a full sleeve shirt!

Nobody is that perfect. To me it just seems too good to be true. Any comments?

bananarama · #26 08-03-2005, 08:03 PM

Am I the only one that doesn't like Kate that much? It's kinda fishy to me that she went from having a pic of him on her wall at school and having the nicname of queen kate or something like that, then she ends up in South America not long after him, then all of a sudden she is in Scotland studying History of Art with him.. I sort of think she put herself in his path in a way which indicates (to me) obsession rather than love. I hope I'm wrong (because I think they'll get married), but I think it would partially explain her "saint kate" image... if she is as cunning as I get the impression she is then she isn't going to blow her chances with her prince now by getting blind drunk in a club and pashing another guy. But like I said, I hope I'm wrong. Maybe she really is in love with him and clean of these things I said entirely (instead of convincing herself she is meant to be queen and convince herself she is in love with him)... Time will tell I suppose.

Well, people were saying things like that about Chelsy too... that she wanted to be "famous", that she had some sort of hope of catching a prince too. If it is within her to do this, and use someone for want of fame, then she does NOT have the character to be a princess and a public figure at all - same for Kate, and any future girlfriend they have...

I don't think either of the girls is better than the other.

I think there has to be a higher standard than simply portraying a happy healthy relationship or person to the press otherwise it will all blow up in their faces... I hope they actually ARE healthy and in this for all the right reasons :) It must be hard for the boys to find girls who genuinly look past the fairytale from Day One but I hope they do, everyone deserves to be loved unconditionally.:p

Harry's polo shirt · #27 08-03-2005, 08:30 PM

Maybe she doesn't want to blow her chances with William..prince or no prince. So she doesn't get drunk at clubs. They were together before they went to college. I think William decided to go to St. Andrews because his friends were going there. Kate wasn't the only one of his friends to attend. No one likes Chelsy because of her morals, We don't see Kate walking around with her boobs hanging out. Therefore Kate is "better" than Chelsey when you look at who has the highest class and morals.
I don't know if Chelsey said she has always wanted to be famous, but looking at who supports their boyfriend the most. I will have to say Kate, because she convinced Will to stay in college, while I read from many different sources that Chelsey didn't want Harry to join the arm so they could spend more time together.

segolen · #28 08-04-2005, 04:44 AM

kool name, bananarama. I've never said that Kate has " a saint image" . i just like her style better.
by the way, where did you get the info that Kate and Wills knew each other long time before St. Andrews?

bananarama · #29 08-04-2005, 06:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by segolen

kool name, bananarama. I've never said that Kate has " a saint image" . i just like her style better.
by the way, where did you get the info that Kate and Wills knew each other long time before St. Andrews?

thanks :)

I never said that you said she had a saint kate image either, simple misunderstanding, I was referring to the media. I remember reading about her being refered to as saint kate, which summed it up to me. Agree totally her fashion is better than Chelsy's though - a bit bland but more appropriate to be photographed so constantly in, (but I don't think Kate the person is better than Chelsy the person - not saying you said that :) I said it lol).

I also never said that they knew each other before St Andrews, I think they met at St Andrews and not before (I am talking of an article that was with her friend Jessica (I think thats her name) in which she said the things about queen kate etc... I don't think Jessica said that Kate knew William before university though, I think they actually met there). I also read that she was in South America (Chile I think?) not long after him. It was simply something I noticed, could be coincidence though but I added all the stuff up I read about her and came to the conclusion that I didn't like her that much. I don't claim to know them, and only have the media to go on who I am aware sensationalises everything.

Hope that cleared that up :)

Idriel · #30 08-04-2005, 06:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bananarama

I also never said that they knew each other before St Andrews, I think they met at St Andrews and not before (I am talking of an article that was with her friend Jessica (I think thats her name) in which she said the things about queen kate etc... I don't think Jessica said that Kate knew William before university though, I think they actually met there). I also read that she was in South America (Chile I think?) not long after him.

Hi bananarama! Your assumptions are right. Kate met William at Saint-Andrews and she was in Chile not long after he went there with the Raleigh.

Princess BellyFlop · #31 08-04-2005, 01:37 PM

Does it really matter whether or not she went after him if she makes him HAPPY and he feels better with her love and support?

sparks · #32 08-04-2005, 01:50 PM

people who cares if she did this..as long as Will is happy than , it's non of our business!!!!

segolen · #33 08-05-2005, 03:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sparks

people who cares if she did this..as long as Will is happy than , it's non of our business!!!!

IT IS. we are free to talk whatever we want.

segolen · #34 08-05-2005, 03:38 AM

....becouse, the royals get paid from our taxes. that's why.

Lisele · #35 08-05-2005, 03:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by segolen

....becouse, the royals get paid from our taxes. that's why.

... since the United States doesn't have a royal family or royal anything, our taxes don't go to the "royals". Their countries pay for them not the United States.

segolen · #36 08-05-2005, 05:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lisele

... since the United States doesn't have a royal family or royal anything, our taxes don't go to the "royals". Their countries pay for them not the United States.

i was talking about UK

polop · #37 08-05-2005, 08:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by segolen

....becouse, the royals get paid from our taxes. that's why.

That's one of the funniest and the most honest things I've heard in a long time!Even though Iam from U.S I feel your pain.While you work hard,the royals go on vacations and spend your hard earned money.Don't worry, it's OK.:)

CasiraghiTrio · #38 08-05-2005, 09:13 PM

I am not really impressed with Chelsy, but I think that Harry would marry her because that seems the kind of crazy thing he would do. I like Harry, don't get me wrong. But he is someone who likes the shock effect and I think he would love the look on Granny One's face if he married wild Chelsy. It would be like a bit like Andrew and Fergie. I'm sure Chelsy would be similar to Fergie in making those early mistakes. Remember how Fergie used to goof up on her public engagements?

I'm sure Harry would want to marry Chelsy for the shock effect because he obviously enjoys being the rebel, but the difficulty might be convincing Charles and the Queen to give their blessing.

tiaraprin · #39 08-05-2005, 10:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lisele

... since the United States doesn't have a royal family or royal anything, our taxes don't go to the "royals". Their countries pay for them not the United States.

While it is certainly true we do not have a royal family, We support a President, Vice President, two houses of Congress, and the Supreme Court all of whom have great health benefits and awesome salaries (which they keep voting to increase). Meanwhile the middle class and the poor have either insufficient or no health insurance and jobs are hard to come by. It doesn't matter where you live, you are always paying the way for someone else to lead a charmed life!

As Benjamin Franklin said "There are only two certainties in life: Death and Taxes." And boy do we get taxed here in the States!!!

Harry's polo shirt · #40 08-05-2005, 10:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tiaraprin

While it is certainly true we do not have a royal family, We support a President, Vice President, two houses of Congress, and the Supreme Court all of whom have great health benefits and awesome salaries (which they keep voting to increase). Meanwhile the middle class and the poor have either insufficient or no health insurance and jobs are hard to come by. It doesn't matter where you live, you are always paying the way for someone else to lead a charmed life!

As Benjamin Franklin said "There are only two certainties in life: Death and Taxes." And boy do we get taxed here in the States!!!

Gotta love Benjamin Franklin..we would be friends