Royal Family Of Albania 1: Ending Aug 2023


If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
See posts with no answers
Status
Not open for further replies.
How wonderful that Sibilla is her godmother but why did it take so long for her to be baptized?

It seems she also received the grand cross in two orders (pictured with her on a couch).
 
But why did Princess Geraldine take so long to be baptized?

It is interesting that Princess Sibilia of Luxembourg was chosen to be godmother.
 
Blog Real said:
But why did Princess Geraldine take so long to be baptized?

It is interesting that Princess Sibilia of Luxembourg was chosen to be godmother.
Click to expand...

Considering her father is Muslim and the House of Zogu has always been officially Muslim despite many Queens and Crown Princesses being of various Christian denominations, I am a little surprised that she was Christened at all.
 
Heavs said:
Considering her father is Muslim and the House of Zogu has always been officially Muslim despite many Queens and Crown Princesses being of various Christian denominations, I am a little surprised that she was Christened at all.
Click to expand...

Likewise. Not to mention that Albania, where as you pointed out earlier the family have a legallly recognized quasi-official status similar to the Romanian royals, is majority-Muslim. Moreover, Islam requires Muslims to raise their children as Muslims.

I wonder if the Catholic baptism might indicate the couple expects to have a son who will succeed his father to his quasi-official position and so consider Geraldine to be dynastically less relevant.
 
Tatiana Maria said:
Likewise. Not to mention that Albania, where as you pointed out earlier the family have a legallly recognized quasi-official status similar to the Romanian royals, is majority-Muslim. Moreover, Islam requires Muslims to raise their children as Muslims.



I wonder if the Catholic baptism might indicate the couple expects to have a son who will succeed his father to his quasi-official position and so consider Geraldine to be dynastically less relevant.
Click to expand...
Princess Geraldine has been called the heir in all the posts I've seen about the christening and have had automatically translated (which could mean that it's not entirely correct). If I remember it correctly the succession under King Zog was "semi-salic" (I think one of his sisters was his heir until he had a son) so maybe she is the heir. Princess Elia is 40 so there might not be more children.
The question of religion in Albania is a bit different from many other countries. From what friends have explained to me for the Albanians being Albanian is more important than what religion you have and I know several in whose families there are several examples of people having married members of another religion.
What puzzles me is that Prince Leka is Muslim, Princess Elia is to my knowledge Orthodox, but Geraldine has been baptized a Catholic.
 
Last edited:
Several messages referenced that princess Sibilla is responsible for her upbringing as a christian (I assume they mean in the Roman Catholic faith), quite a task if her parents are muslim and Eastern Orthodox. Is anything known about the godfathers background (other than him being a friend of the couple?).
 
Somebody said:
How wonderful that Sibilla is her godmother but why did it take so long for her to be baptized?

It seems she also received the grand cross in two orders (pictured with her on a couch).
Click to expand...

Possibly the pandemic paused things.

Geraldine was christened on her paternal grandmother Queen Susan's birthday.
 
Somebody said:
Is anything known about the godfathers background (other than him being a friend of the couple?).
Click to expand...

Thomas Frashëri is the chairman of the Electronic and Postal Communications Authority in Albania and a former advisor the the Albanian Prime Minister.
 
An Ard Ri said:
I thought the Albanian Crown Prince was Muslim and his wife was Eastern Orthodox but the children seem to have had a Catholic baptism?

After post I see this was discussed above but it also puzzled me?
Click to expand...

I believe the Royal House did communicate that they wanted a Catholic baptism to stress the multi-religiosity of the Albanian community.

The Roman and the Orthodox Churches fully recognize each other's priests, the validity of the Seven Sacraments (including Baptism) conducted by both Churches and recognize the reality that both Churches sprang from one common “Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church”, being one in the same, until 1054 A.D.
 
I'd also forgotten that Queen Geraldine was a Hungarian Roman Catholic!
 
Duc_et_Pair said:
I believe the Royal House did communicate that they wanted a Catholic baptism to stress the multi-religiosity of the Albanian community.
Click to expand...

Apparently so.

https://albanianroyalcourt.al/communique-de-la-maison-royale/

"The baptism of Princess Geraldine is part of the Royal House's family tradition which has always reflected the multi-confessional character of the country".

https://albanianroyalcourt.al/royal-house/

"An excellent example of religious co-existence is reflected in the Royal Family: The Queen Mother Sadije Toptani was a Bektashi Muslim, King Zog a Sunni Muslim, Queen Geraldine a Catholic, Queen Susan an Anglican. Prince Leka is Muslim and Princess Elia is an Albanian Orthodox."
 
JR76 said:
Princess Geraldine has been called the heir in all the posts I've seen about the christening and have had automatically translated (which could mean that it's not entirely correct).
Click to expand...

I think your automatic translation is likely to be correct, as an English-language feature article on Leka II last year backs it up:

https://www.theatlantic.com/magazin...-crown-prince-albania-europe-monarchy/629368/

When I asked about succession, Leka told me he would ask Princess Geraldine, when she turned 18, if she wanted to be his heir. “Legally, according to the Albanian royal constitution, it would go directly to the first male,” he said. But the rules can be fudged, not least because Zog’s laws were overhauled by the Italians, and then the Communists, and the constitution has no legal standing.​


JR76 said:
If I remember it correctly the succession under King Zog was "semi-salic" (I think one of his sisters was his heir until he had a son)
Click to expand...

Under the 1928 constitution of the then-kingdom of Albania, the succession to the throne was male-only:

Art. 50. The King of the Albanians is His Majesty Zog I, of the illustrious Albanian family of Zogu.
Art. 51. The Heir to the Throne shall be the King's eldest son. and the succession shall continue generation after generation in the direct male line.
Art. 52. Should the Heir die or lose his rights to the Throne, his eldest son shall succeed.
Should the Heir to the Throne die or lose his rights and leave no son, the succession shall pass to the brother coming after him.
Art. 53. Should there be no Heir to the Throne under articles 51 and 52, the King shall select his successor from among the male members of his family, but the King's selection shall be with the consent of Parliament.
Should the King not use his prerogative, and the succession remain vacant, Parliament shall then select a male member of the King's family as successor to the Throne.
In case no heirs exist in the King's family, or such as may exist are held incapable by a special parliamentary decision taken by a two-thirds majority of the members of the House, Parliament shall select a successor from the line of the King's daughters or sisters, but such successor must be of Albanian origin.
When there are no males in the families above mentioned, Parliament shall select a successor of Albanian origin.
Should the Throne remain vacant, the Council of Ministers shall exercise the Royal powers until the question of the successor is settled.
Click to expand...

https://albanianroyalcourt.al/the-albanian-royal-court/
 
Tatiana Maria said:
Under the 1928 constitution of the then-kingdom of Albania, the succession to the throne was male-only:
Click to expand...
That I wrote "semi-salic" in my previous post, was my way of saying that I neither remembered more about the succession than that it wasn't salic nor what the definition would be. According to your post it is/was one of cognatic male primogeniture.
Tatiana Maria said:
https://albanianroyalcourt.al/the-albanian-royal-court/
Click to expand...
I'm quoting from the profile of Princess Nafije on the royal website:
"Princess Nafije (1896-1955) married Ceno Bey Kryeziu from Kosova. They had a son, Tati Essad Murad Kryeziu, on whom King Zog bestowed the title “The Prince of Kosova”. He was the heir presumptive until 1939. Prince Tati had a number of official duties in supporting the youth and sports. He held the honorary rank of Colonel of the Royal Guard."
Prince Tati is the little boy in the picture together with his uncle, his mother, his grandmother and some of his aunts.
https://albanianroyalcourt.al/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/princesses_of_albania.jpg
 
Last edited:
But Roman Catholic baptism requires a Roman Catholic upbringing for the child.
 
JR76 said:
That I wrote "semi-salic" in my previous post, was my way of saying that I neither remembered more about the succession than that it wasn't salic nor what the definition would be. According to your post it is/was one of cognatic male primogeniture.
Click to expand...

I'm not familiar with the term "cognatic male", but I think "Salic" is the usual description for the situation wherein only males in the direct male line were in the line of succession to the throne.

JR76 said:
I'm quoting from the profile of Princess Nafije on the royal website:
"Princess Nafije (1896-1955) married Ceno Bey Kryeziu from Kosova. They had a son, Tati Essad Murad Kryeziu, on whom King Zog bestowed the title “The Prince of Kosova”. He was the heir presumptive until 1939. Prince Tati had a number of official duties in supporting the youth and sports. He held the honorary rank of Colonel of the Royal Guard."
Prince Tati is the little boy in the picture together with his uncle, his mother, his grandmother and some of his aunts.
https://albanianroyalcourt.al/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/princesses_of_albania.jpg
Click to expand...

Thank you, I hadn't seen that paragraph. I'm not sure how to reconcile "He was the heir presumptive until 1939" with the provisions of the 1928 constitution (assuming there is no major error in translation on either page), unless the meaning is that the King intended to select him as his successor with the consent of Parliament pursuant to Article 53 in the absence of a legal heir to the throne.
 
Biri said:
But Roman Catholic baptism requires a Roman Catholic upbringing for the child.
Click to expand...

I haven't read anywhere that Princess Geraldine was NOT going to be brought up Roman Catholic. I doubt the baptism was just for show.
 
Biri said:
But Roman Catholic baptism requires a Roman Catholic upbringing for the child.
Click to expand...

It requires a Christian upbringing for the child and the mother is a Christian.
 
Duc_et_Pair said:
It requires a Christian upbringing for the child and the mother is a Christian.
Click to expand...

My parish says that unless the baptism is done in an emergency(imminent death, for example) the parents must agree to have the child raised Catholic. They do not need to be Catholic themselves.

Edited to add: Cannon law 868 says the best attempt must me made to raise the child Catholic.
 
Last edited:
Noble Consort Ming said:
My parish says that unless the baptism is done in an emergency(imminent death, for example) the parents must agree to have the child raised Catholic. They do not need to be Catholic themselves.

Edited to add: Cannon law 868 says the best attempt must me made to raise the child Catholic.
Click to expand...

How to match this with the fact that Catholics already recognize any baptism done with water (pouring or full immersion) with the proper Trinitarian formula to be valid? Protestants or Orthodox who convert to Catholicism are not re-baptized.

As the Orthodox Faith has 99% the same principles as the Catholics (but a way deeper mystic feel) all will come well with a proper "Catholic" upbringing of the child. I would not count all the folks whom have a baptism and for the rest give their child a pracitcally full atheist upbringing. The Archbishop will be relieved that at least the child is baptized, in whatever form.
 
Duc_et_Pair said:
How to match this with the fact that Catholics already recognize any baptism done with water (pouring or full immersion) with the proper Trinitarian formula to be valid? Protestants or Orthodox who convert to Catholicism are not re-baptized.

As the Orthodox Faith has 99% the same principles as the Catholics (but a way deeper mystic feel) all will come well with a proper "Catholic" upbringing of the child. I would not count all the folks whom have a baptism and for the rest give their child a pracitcally full atheist upbringing. The Archbishop will be relieved that at least the child is baptized, in whatever form.
Click to expand...

Yes, the church recognizes any trinitarian baptism even if done by a lay person but does not consider those so baptized to be Catholics until they choose to convert. It just means they do not have to be baptized again.

You don't know if the the archbishop is relieved and cannot really speak for him. If canon law means nothing to you that is your business but it means something to many people.

Many people do not like the idea of religious ceremonies being done simply for show. In this case however I believe and hope that the couple intend to raise their daughter as a Catholic, the faith of the great grandmother she is named after.

In some parts of the world there is strife between the Catholic and Orthodox faiths so to say they are 99% the same over simplifies the matter. There are some major theological differences that happen to be important to members of both faiths.

But I realize you just HAVE to be right about everything so I will step away from this conversation. I do not agree with what you're saying and frankly I'm not sure you even agree with what you're saying. You just want to be right and have the last word. So go ahead and have it.
 
Noble Consort Ming said:
But I realize you just HAVE to be right about everything so I will step away from this conversation. I do not agree with what you're saying and frankly I'm not sure you even agree with what you're saying. You just want to be right and have the last word. So go ahead and have it.
Click to expand...

I think those of us who have regularly read Duc's posts will have noted his respectfulness to other posters, even when, unfortunately, that respect is not being reciprocated.

Your explanation of what Catholic church law says on the subject is welcome (I have looked it up and quoted it below for anyone else who may be interested), but for those of us who are not experts on the subject it is a logical, albeit flawed, assumption that the church's recognition of baptisms of other churches might mean similar acceptance of upbringing in those other churches. It is puzzling to me that you describe that natural assumption as "wanting to be right" and "not sure you even agree with what you're saying".

Of course, the entire question is hypothetical, since it is quite possible for Princess Geraldine's parents to have her raised Catholic in spite of not being Catholic themselves, and that seems to be acceptable under the Catholic church rules:

https://www.vatican.va/archive/cod-iuris-canonici/eng/documents/cic_lib4-cann834-878_en.html#PART_I.

Can. 844 §1. Catholic ministers administer the sacraments licitly to Catholic members of the Christian faithful alone, who likewise receive them licitly from Catholic ministers alone, without prejudice to the prescripts of §§2, 3, and 4 of this canon, and can. 861, §2.

[...]

Can. 851 The celebration of baptism must be prepared properly; consequently: [...]

2/ the parents of an infant to be baptized and those who are to undertake the function of sponsor are to be instructed properly on the meaning of this sacrament and the obligations attached to it. The pastor personally or through others is to take care that the parents are properly instructed through both pastoral advice and common prayer, bringing several families together and, where possible, visiting them.

[...]

Can. 868 §1. For an infant to be baptized licitly:

1/ the parents or at least one of them or the person who legitimately takes their place must consent;

2/ there must be a founded hope that the infant will be brought up in the Catholic religion; if such hope is altogether lacking, the baptism is to be delayed according to the prescripts of particular law after the parents have been advised about the reason.
Click to expand...

In terms of religious duties, it would seem to me that the problem is not so much with Princess Geraldine as with Crown Prince Leka, since he is not fulfilling his responsibility as a Muslim to pass the Muslim faith on to his child.
 
Duc_et_Pair said:
I believe the Royal House did communicate that they wanted a Catholic baptism to stress the multi-religiosity of the Albanian community.

The Roman and the Orthodox Churches fully recognize each other's priests, the validity of the Seven Sacraments (including Baptism) conducted by both Churches and recognize the reality that both Churches sprang from one common “Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church”, being one in the same, until 1054 A.D.
Click to expand...

Many say High Church Anglicanism/Anglo Catholicism is simply "Rome without the Pope" but that doesn't change the fact that in the last 500 years some major theological and ideological differences have occurred, even though it's still one of the closest strands of Christianity to RC and the liturgy is very similar. Go back 1000 years and there are incredible schisms! That's why they split in the first place. And the liturgy is very different. There are large political and theological schisms within Eastern Orthodoxy and Roman Catholicism as well. It's very simplistic to say that it doesn't matter because for 1000 years they were the same thing because everyone still uses certain ancient creeds. And I'm someone who *wishes* the Church Universalis would actually stop pointless bickering.

Whilst I understand the family's desire to appeal to all sectors of the Albanian people, I question how it's going to work in practice when neither of her parents or living grandparents are Catholic and most of her godparents won't be around regularly. It all becomes rather hollow (and yes I know many are christened these days just because it's tradition and not because the parents believe), like the family are trying to get points for diversity rather than it being any indication of how Geraldine will *actually* be brought up religiously. The royal equivalent of those who think that liking a post on social media is the same as advocating for a cause. All IMHO of course.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Marengo
Royal Family of Albania 2, Aug 2023 -
2
Replies
54
Views
5K
Blog Real
Blog Real
A
Future and Popularity of the Thai Monarchy
2 3 4
Replies
99
Views
11K
Tatiana Maria
T
ROYAL NORWAY
Golden Wedding Anniversary of King Harald V and Queen Sonja
2 3
Replies
62
Views
13K
eya
E
HMQueenElizabethII
Relationship of the Royal Family with The Duchess of Cornwall
11 12 13
Replies
384
Views
100K
Marc23
M
Blueice
  • Locked
Royal Family of Serbia current events 2: February 2005 - Aug 2023
18 19 20
Replies
598
Views
140K
Marengo
Marengo

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom