Ratzinger was never truly anywhere near as popular within the Church or especially with the secular media as JPII or Francis, despite his warm reception at the Youth Day event which took place soon after his election as pope.
He was still within the honeymoon phase of his pontificate at that World Youth Day 2005, and
every pope can expect a rapturous welcome at such an event quite frankly.
But the tide turned quickly against him and he ended up receiving a lot of criticism and blame he may or may not have deserved in the wake of the Church's sex abuse scandals.
I don't agree with this.
Benedict received a lot of undeserved criticism from the secular media in the wake of the Church's sex abuse scandals, but he also received a lot of praise throughout his pontificate.
He also received a warm reception at almost every foreign visits from 2005 to 2013.
But the secular media turned against him after Francis was elected. He has been depressed in recent years, and I have read that he is very sensitive and is very hurt by what the press writes.
I should know this because I am very interested in the papacy, and I've read countless books and articles on this subject.
And I think when he dies the media will go crazy, and be full of praise for him.
Especially since the election of Jesuit Jorge Cardinal Bergoglio there is a widespread perception of Ratzinger as doctrinaire and intolerant. Francis is a "breath of fresh air" and the "People's Pope" which is nonsense.
Just like Benedict XVI, Francis I has condemned abortion in the strictest terms, and just the other day he stood before the US Congress and made a thinly veiled criticism of same sex marriage when he warned about the danger to traditional families.
The difference between Francis and his predecessors is nothing more than a difference in style, not substance.
Yes, he is very conservative, but he doesn't speak so much about the controversial issues. We must remeber that he have a whole bunch of new PR advisers.
Pope Francis is also a very strong and confident person, and he has said many stupid things in the past two years.
I've also noticed that he has been much more criticized lately, and as a Catholic priest / expert said not so long ago ''had Francis been Pope in 2009, then we would have had major problems, because he changes his mind all the time''.
But I like that he's talking about the poor, and women in the church, but it seems like it's just talk.
And he has been criticized for these stupid statements, and rightly so.
Full transcript of Pope's in-flight interview from Cuba to US :: Catholic News Agency (CNA)