. Somehow i really have to believe that both of the York girls are never going to set the world on fire for fashion.
Well, on the evidence to date, I think there are many who would agree with you. In my very humble opinion, I think that one of the difficulties that both girls face is that their mother Sarah has little inherent fashion sense, and if you have a fashion-aware mother, you can often be guided in your choices. What the Princesses really needed before setting off for Westminster Abbey [and preferably before they even purchased their dresses and THAT HAT] was a stylish mother to say ' Oh, not that Dress', or 'Eeeeek you can't wear that hat'. And as I have said elsewhere in this forum, I think that the the Designers and Milliner let the Princesses down very badly as well.
By mentinoning Sarah's lack of early style, I particularly want to stress that I do NOT want this statement to be seen as 'Sarah-bashing'. Instead, please let me try to put this remark into context.
When Sarah joined the Royal Family, many of her outfits were, quite frankly, a disgrace to the Designers who sold them to her. Both 'The Times' and 'Tatler' magazine highlighted the 'Droopy Flower Print frocks' that Sarah appeared in. The important point however was that whilst Diana was the 'stick-thin [which we now know was in part due to her eating disorders] fashion plate', 'Fergie' was big, bouncy and good fun. She joined in very enthusiastically with all the activities the BRF love [horses, country life at Balmoral, weekends at Windsor Castle where the Duke of Edinburgh taught her Carriage Driving].
In the early days of her marriage, the RF quite obviously adored Sarah, praising the way that she joined in with everything and how she was learning to fly etc. [Prince Charles is also rumoured at one point to have said to Diana 'Why can't you be more like Sarah?' A remark quoted in the broadsheets, not just the tabloids.
It was also at that time that people were starting to become a little jaded with the apparent vanity of the Princess of Wales - it was not only the tabloids that published the enormous sums that Diana was apparently spending on clothes and at a time of increasing national austerity, to the general dismay of many royal 'Royal Watchers' including many of the RF's loyal fans; the INITIAL effect of all this was put Sarah's lack of fashion sense 'on the back burner', as it didn't seem to matter so much.
Having obviously been guided well in the choice of her wedding dress, it seemed that after the wedding Sarah started to 'do her own choosing with no guidance', and her lack of fashion-savvy soon showed, but at first, it didn't seem to be important - whereas fashion and charity was Diana's 'thing', Sarah had a host of other activities in addition to her her charity work and fashion was a bit of an irrelevant facet of her life.
Ultimately, when the criticism started to become vocal, Sarah began to take good and sensible advice from professionals who really knew what they were talking about, and when she did so, she often looked very good. The problem however was that when she was not guided well, or when she had taken poor advice, her dressing faults always showed. In my very humble opinion, it is my view that left to her own ideas, Sarah has no inbuilt fashion-radar. Develop this idea further, and let us assume that if the Princesses ever ask their mother for an opinion as to how they look or what suits them, Sarah is not necessarily going to be the best person to advise them. Extrapolate this idea a little, and think what would have been the case if Diana had both lived and had had the daughter she always wanted. With Diana's fashion sense, one would imagine that there would not have been so many fashion mistakes sported by her little Princess.
Only my views,
Alex