I think you are being slightly hypersensitive Rascal. It is a fact that American's eat more, have larger portions, and are in general a larger people. It is not to hard of an assumption to make that moving to America can make it much harder to stay thin. Personally, I think Mado pulls of the extra weight! She looks sexy.
I agree with your description of the average American's weight, but the insulting comment was about the style and color choice and implies that because the choice in the poster's opinion is bad it must be caused by the influence Madde has been under since being in America. If it was about her weight specifically I would have overlooked it...as I have done in the past.
BTW...I agree completely with you about Madde and weight. She has never looked unhealthy. I looked back at the thread about who has the best body among the royals and at the time I was surprised to find that I chose CP Mary because she looked much better then. Now... ! No hips, no butt, no breasts...she has one of the worst bodies. And even though she has always been thin...Letizia just looks terrible. Even when smiling they both seem very irritated and angry most of the time. I much prefer a softer, feminine form. If only Madeleine could get a clue or find a stylist who really understands her body and dresses her appropriately. More often than not, Madde misses the mark. The last time she looked really good to me was for Vic's wedding...a little Barbie-ish but it worked.