Future and Popularity of the Spanish Monarchy


If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
See posts with no answers
I say let the people decide. Maybe Spain would be better off without a monarchy. An automatic passing of the crown is apparently not what the people want. It's like forcing them to accept without really being heard.

Sent from my SCH-I545 using The Royals Community mobile app
 
:previous:
Why would Spain be better off. It's economic problems will be the same. Republic or Monarchy.
 
I guess the abdication has opened the floodgates,hopefully once Felipe settles into his role as Monarch the calls for a referendum will gradually dissipate.
 
royalistbert said:
:previous:
Why would Spain be better off. It's economic problems will be the same. Republic or Monarchy.
Click to expand...

I agree - I fail to see how Spain would in any way be better off if it suddenly became a republic. Of-course if at least 75p/c of the population wanted a republic, then society in general would be happier with a president instead of a king, but all of the economic problems will remain the same.
 
Being like Spanish politicians are, would be much worse.

The protests are against the monarchy, and in many cases against the Spanish political and institutional system. No serious democratic country, can change the form of State every 30 or 40 years ... and Spain in the last two centuries has had too many such experiments.

The leftist movements, republicans, independence groups ... always organized large demonstrations and make lots of noise. But if they really want changes, they will not succeed with banners and shouting, it must achieve with elections and in the Parliament. They are experts in promising things and tell people what they want to hear, but that often collide with the reality of today's world.

The economic crisis has increased the discontent of the people, especially the youth with the system... now the head of the system changes, and thus gives way to another generation to another way of seeing things and that will give way to change.
 
Usual Spaniards face difficulties anyway and are said to leave the country. King Felipe will not be much better than his father. The novelty of hope and change wears off very fast.
 
Felipe will have to assist the reform of the political system that is sick to the core, in the end he may abolish himself if this is what Spain wants.
 
Aren't the only protests of note in Madrid and Barcelona? Not surprising due to the present economic situation, every time I visited these cities in the last years there was some sort of demonstration going on. A referendum at this point doesn't make sense and it won't be fair as the issue is not the monarchy alone but the entire system. The rapid organisation of these protests show that existing organised anti-government groups are behind it.

The protests seem rather ungrateful, JC shot an elephant but that hardly erases his role in Spain, esp. the role he played in the process of democratisation of the country. A role that these very protestors are profiting from at the moment.
 
Last edited:
Al_bina said:
King Felipe will not be much better than his father.
Click to expand...

Well, my impression is that he is more demure. Surely he won't hunt elephants and will be loyal to his wife :flowers:.

And yes, Duke of Marmelade, a reform under the auspices of Felipe might indeed happen, and yes, I do believe he would step back, if this would help. Though I don't believe he would do it lightheartedly. It will be interesting to watch future developements unfolding.
 
Being demure and having a wholesome PR image (not hunting elephants and being loyal to his wife) mean nothing to people facing problems. It would be difficult to determine what kind reforms King Felipe can initiate or support. One might assume another round of austerity measures are going to happen soon.
 
Those are stupid details for joke ... King Juan Carlos has always hunted ... the problem is to go to a luxury hunting in Africa in the worst week of the economic crisis with the country to collapse.

The Crown, as political parties and other Spanish institutions are aware of they have reached a point when a change is necessary... and in that change is key a generational change. It should go from those who made the transition and now have more than 70 years, to those who grew up with it and are in their 40s.

If the Head of State himself understands it, probably other institutions follow the same process ... and they must do because it is inevitable for them to survive.
 
TLLK said:
So for now the constitution has to be amended to allow for JC's abdication and an amendment for primogeniture regardless of gender?
Click to expand...

No, a "normal" Bill will be offered to the Cortes (the Parliament) regarding the intention of the King to abdicate the kingship in favour of his legal successor, the Prince of Asturias.

Constitution of the Kingdom of Spain
Section 57
1. The Crown of Spain shall be inherited by the successors of His Majesty Don Juan Carlos I de Borbón, the legitimate heir of the historic dynasty. [...]
5. Abdications and renunciations in connection with the succession to the Crown shall be settled by an organic Act.
 
Cory said:
There are republican groups which organized riots in favour of the republic in different cities forgetting the disaster of the two spanish republics:

Voces republicanas en las plazas | Espa?a | EL MUNDO
Click to expand...

This weekend will see the annual Armed Forces Day, the last one presided by the King. Then large crowds are attracted to the spectacle and usually loud cheers, applause and "Viva El Rey!" is shouted. Republican tendences are of all times in Spain, the division developed since the Civil War still exists and is cultivated. At the same time there are also areas in Spain where Franco is seen as "not too bad" for Spain.
 
Fortunately the majority of the people is in favour of Monarchy and of the future King Felipe VI.

There is a royalist majority in the country.

There is only a minority for the republic.

All the polls show more than 60% of the population are in favour of the future King Felipe VI.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Cory said:
Fortunately the majority of the people is in favour of Monarchy and of the future King Felipe VI.
Click to expand...


I remember reading an article (sorry, can't recall what it was called or where I was actually reading it) that said popularity for the Spanish Monarchy had dropped to 48%, I do hop that isn't true but with all these protests and demonstrations it's looking like the Spaniards really want rid of the House of Bourbon :(
 
lula said:
Being like Spanish politicians are, would be much worse.

The protests are against the monarchy, and in many cases against the Spanish political and institutional system. No serious democratic country, can change the form of State every 30 or 40 years ... and Spain in the last two centuries has had too many such experiments.

The leftist movements, republicans, independence groups ... always organized large demonstrations and make lots of noise. But if they really want changes, they will not succeed with banners and shouting, it must achieve with elections and in the Parliament. They are experts in promising things and tell people what they want to hear, but that often collide with the reality of today's world.

The economic crisis has increased the discontent of the people, especially the youth with the system... now the head of the system changes, and thus gives way to another generation to another way of seeing things and that will give way to change.
Click to expand...

The two main national parties (the Conservative PP and the Socialist PSOE) support the monarchy. Unless that changes, I don't see republicanism getting any further new ground in Spain.
 
Yes, the monarchy has fallen in surveys ... but as I said in recent years, with the crisis, people is very unhappy and all institutions have fallen...

The results of the Royal Family are bad, results of politicians are absolutely terrible ... so they can hardly be seen as a good alternative.
 
Well I suppose that's going to happen with any institution in an nation that people think isn't producing, people automatically see that institution as irrelevant and in need of removing, even over here in the UK the monarchy has its bad & good days, I do hope that the people of Spain will allow Prince Philip to prove himself
 
Spain as a country there seems to be a lot of protest anyway.
 
royalistbert said:
Spain as a country there seems to be a lot of protest anyway.
Click to expand...
This is the most accurate post of the night ;)

Yes, Republican parties are certainly big in Spain and they´re protesting all over the country, but I don´t think is so worrying. It was expected that they would protest when this day would come.

We´ll have to wait a bit longer to see which this leads to.
 
Cory can you provide links for these polls in future,thanks.
 
I think it is very important for republican and monarchy supporters alike to be able to demonstrate and have their voices heard publicly without fear of arrest or worse. In fact to my mind, there is more democracy in having the ability to protest unhindered than there is in having the ability to elect one's head of state once in a blue moon.
Accordingly, the protesters are using their democratic right to protest and that is a good thing. Naturally, as the majority of people support the system of monarchy, democracy is continually served by retaining said monarchy. I would go as far as to say that the monarchy is as democratic as a republic with similar levels of support.
 
A poll of Spaniards in January by Sigma Dos gave Felipe a 66% approval rating, compared with 41% for his father:

http://online.wsj.com/articles/spanish-king-juan-carlos-to-abdicate-prime-minister-says-1401699434

More than half of Spaniards want king to abdicate: poll | Repost - The Future of Content is Here

It won't be easy for the future Felipe VI:

Juan Carlos abdication sparks calls for referendum on Spain's monarchy | World news | theguardian.com

We will see how the reaction of the people will be at the accession to the Throne of King Felipe VI.

Popular support for Spain’s monarchy plummets - World Socialist Web Site
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Jacknch said:
I think it is very important for republican and monarchy supporters alike to be able to demonstrate and have their voices heard publicly without fear of arrest or worse. In fact to my mind, there is more democracy in having the ability to protest unhindered than there is in having the ability to elect one's head of state once in a blue moon.
Accordingly, the protesters are using their democratic right to protest and that is a good thing. Naturally, as the majority of people support the system of monarchy, democracy is continually served by retaining said monarchy. I would go as far as to say that the monarchy is as democratic as a republic with similar levels of support.
Click to expand...
Agree on everything :)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

An Ard Ri
  • Sticky
Birthday and anniversary wishes for the Royal Family of the Spain 2024
Replies
12
Views
980
Biri
B
Blog Real
King Lodovico I, King Lodovico II and Kingdom of Etruria
Replies
3
Views
609
Blog Real
Blog Real
Stefan
Jewels worn by Members of the Spanish Royal Family 2: Jun 2023 -
Replies
6
Views
831
An Ard Ri
An Ard Ri
Blog Real
Kings Ferdinand I, Francis I, Ferdinand II, Francis II & Kingdom of the Two Sicilies
Replies
2
Views
508
CyrilVladisla
CyrilVladisla
theroyalfly
"Ena and Bee: Queen Victoria’s Spanish Granddaughters" by Ana de Sagrera (2022)
Replies
1
Views
711
Alison H
A

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom