BeatrixFan
Majesty , Royal Blogger, TRF Author
- Joined
- Jul 18, 2005
- Messages
- 6,861
- City
- London
- Country
- United Kingdom
Returning to Britain was never an option, war or no war. In the event they were given the option to redeem themselves.... out of harms way, in the Bahama's.
I disagree. Most of the public were supportive of the Duke and I believe would have been happy to let them reside in England as long as they lived as peers rather than Royals. The Duke must have had the right to sit in the Lords but they could have made special provision to deny him that. What harm could it do to have the Windsors living a private life on a private estate? I think if they'd have gone down that route then the Windsors would have had a much nicer life. And then, when the war came along, they could have done their bit and redeemed their reputation a little - I'm sure it could have been done and it was a viable option but one that was never looked into. If they were good enough to act as British diplomats, they were good enough to reside on British soil.
In those dark days the King and Queen had to be the rallying point of a nation. Staunchly backing the government and the Prime Minister. A pro-Nazi ex King could have divided the nation. It could even have lost Britain the war. (A house divided against itself cannot stand! Not exactly the "Queen Mother effect!").
I don't believe David could ever have been King but we had plenty of pro-Nazis in Britain, Sir Oswald Mosely and his wife Diana to name but two. I fail to see why in a democratic country, we can't have private citizens who hold extreme right views. If the majority want to follow those views then they will but that didn't happen and I can't see why the Duke and Duchess of Windsor in their private status couldn't have returned to England and live a private existance. Personally I think any political affiliation would have been a mistake but if they did, they'd be doing so as private citizens and I don't see that as a problem or divisive to the nation unless you're suggesting there was possible mandate for a Nazi majority in Britain. But politics aside, and if they had remained totally apolitical, I don't see why they couldn't have visited the bombed out East End just as the Queen Mother did (as Queen) - after all, the Duke was popular there, more popular than the Queen Mother when she first visited. And if that had have happened, I'm sure that it would have been very different after the war with the Windsors held in a very different regard.